Mura CMS bug and mod_rewrite workaround: 200 OK instead of 404 error

I've discovered a bit of a bug in the way Mura CMS handles 404s and wanted to share my workaround. Valid path_info for Mura pages consist of only letters, numbers, hyphens and forward slashes. If you browse to a path that doesn't exists, Mura properly throws a 404 error -- well, sometimes...

If it's a valid Mura formatted URL, you'll get a 404. For example:

...however, if the path_info is not "valid," Mura seems to ignore it and display the home page -- for example:

On some sites, you might not care about this, but Google and other spiders can become very suspicious when non-existent URLs return a 200 response instead of a 404. I discovered this when our SEO/content guru was having trouble getting Google Webmaster tools to verify after I uploaded the specified uniquely-named html file. Google refused to authenticate us, because they were attempting to "test" for a 404 and instead got 200 responses. I assume they just make up a random file name or path and expect a 404. It makes sense that they want to ensure that the site doesn't return a 200 OK for everything, because they can not count on the 200 from the authenticity file/URL to be true.

You can leverage URL rewriting as one workaround, as I have. Based on the standard default site URL format of Mura CMS, you can use something like the following with Apache mod_rewrite to force a Mura 404 when an "invalid" path_info exists:

RewriteEngine On
RewriteRule ^/default/index.cfm/([^a-zA-Z0-9/-]+)$ /default/index.cfm/force-a-404-error/ [PT,L]

Comments (Comment Moderation is enabled. Your comment will not appear until approved.)
Matt Levine's Gravatar Interest bug, we'll look into it and hopefully get a fix in the code soon.

# Posted By Matt Levine | 6/4/09 2:55 PM
Jamie Krug's Gravatar @Matt: Hey, you're quick, thanks!
# Posted By Jamie Krug | 6/4/09 3:28 PM
Andy Ford's Gravatar @Jamie - That quickness is due to the magic of TweetDeck filters!
# Posted By Andy Ford | 6/4/09 4:27 PM
BlogCFC was created by Raymond Camden.